Papaya is a small light green cucumber. She grows long brown hair and has a small nose. She is usually seen wearing a yellow bow on her head and a yellow, white and blue dress. In another appearance she has orange hair. When she acted as a carrot, she was colored orange. In her next appearance, she wears a white hat with blue and pink flowers, with a matching colored shirt and a blue vest and a pink belt.
- Herself in "God Made You Special"
- Mexican Girl in "Minnesota Cuke And The Search For Noah's Umbrella"
- Herself and The Unnamed Cucumber Girl in "Saint Nicholas A Story Of Joyful Giving"
- Herself in "Silly Little Thing Called Love"
- Herself in "Happy Together"
- Herself "Twas The Night Before Easter"
- Herself in "Princess And The Popstar A Story Of Trading Places"
- Lavinia and Teenage Papaya in "The Penniless Princess God's Little Girl"
- The Unnamed Cucumber Girl in "Merry Larry and the True Light of Christmas"
- The Unnamed Cucumber Girl in "Beauty and the Beet"
- The Unnamed Cucumber Girl in "Larry-Boy and the Non Gentle Giant Robot: A VeggieTales Movie"